Skip to Content
L. Patrick Mulligan & Associates, LLC L. Patrick Mulligan & Associates, LLC
Call Us Today! 937-685-7006

Defending Against Federal Fraud Charges: Legal Strategies

Regarding legal battles involving federal fraud charges, the stakes are undeniably high. Whether you find yourself accused of securities fraud, healthcare fraud, or any other form of fraudulent activity, the consequences of a conviction can be severe. That's why it's crucial to approach your defense with a strong strategy in mind.

A solid defense strategy can help protect your rights, freedom, and future. This strategy requires careful planning, thorough investigation, and the insights of a skilled attorney. By crafting compelling arguments, you can challenge the prosecution's evidence, present alternative theories, and cast doubt on their case against you.

At L. Patrick Mulligan & Associates, LLC, we stand up for those in Dayton facing federal fraud charges. Schedule a consultation by calling (937) 685-7006.

What Is Considered Federal Fraud?

Understanding what constitutes an offense is crucial to navigating the intricate world of federal fraud charges. Federal fraud can be broadly defined as the intentional use of deception, misrepresentation, or omission to unlawfully obtain property, services, or benefits for oneself or others. The crime must impact the federal government or cross state or international boundaries to fall under federal authority.

Examples of federal fraud include the following:

  • Mail and wire fraud: Using the mail or electronic communications to carry out fraudulent schemes.
  • Tax fraud: Willfully providing false information or evading taxes owed to the federal government.
  • Securities fraud: Using material, non-public information to affect buying and selling decisions in the financial markets.
  • Healthcare fraud: Engaging in fraudulent billing practices or making false claims for medical services or procedures.

Now, let's address the consequences and penalties associated with federal fraud convictions. The range of punishment can vary depending on the specific offense and the severity of the fraudulent activity. In many cases, federal fraud prison sentences can span months to decades. That's not all—fines imposed upon conviction can range from thousands to millions of dollars, and individuals may be required to pay restitution to the victims or the government.

The impact of a federal fraud conviction extends far beyond just serving time or paying fines. Such a conviction can tarnish personal and professional reputations, making securing future employment or engaging in certain industries challenging. The penalties are substantial, and that's why it's crucial to mount a strong defense and explore every possible legal avenue to challenge the charges against you.

Legal Defenses for Federal Fraud Charges

When facing federal fraud charges, understanding the potential legal defenses at your disposal is crucial. These defenses can help challenge the prosecution's case and provide an opportunity to establish your innocence or mitigate the severity of the charges against you. Let's explore three common legal defenses used in federal fraud cases: lack of intent, mistaken identity, and entrapment.

Lack of Intent

Proving intent is a crucial element in fraud cases. Intent refers to the conscious purpose or knowledge of engaging in fraudulent activity. The prosecution must demonstrate that you intended to deceive, misrepresent, or omit information to obtain property, services, or benefits unlawfully.

A lack of intent defense can be effective in some situations. For example, suppose you can demonstrate that you were unaware of the fraudulent scheme or establish that your actions resulted from a mistake, misunderstanding, or innocent oversight. In that case, it can cast doubt on the prosecution's claim of intent.

Mistaken Identity

Individuals sometimes find themselves wrongly accused of federal fraud due to mistaken identity. It's not unheard of for law enforcement or prosecutors to misidentify a person as the perpetrator of a fraudulent act. In such situations, gathering evidence to establish an alibi or present information that proves you were not present or involved in the fraudulent activity is essential.

Building a persuasive defense against mistaken identity requires a comprehensive investigation and collection of evidence. This may involve obtaining witness testimonies, surveillance footage, financial records, or other relevant documentation to help establish your innocence. By diligently challenging the accuracy of the identification, you can undermine the prosecution's case and raise a reasonable doubt about your involvement.


Entrapment is another potential defense in federal fraud cases. It refers to situations where law enforcement officers or government agents induce or persuade an individual to commit a crime they would not have otherwise committed. The critical aspect of entrapment is the element of government inducement.

To successfully demonstrate entrapment, you must show that law enforcement officials coerced, manipulated, or pressured you to engage in the fraudulent act. This defense requires careful examination of your case's facts and a thorough understanding of entrapment laws.

Building a Strong Defense Strategy

Developing a compelling defense strategy can help protect your rights and allow you to pursue a just outcome in your case.

Below are three key components of a robust defense:

  • Early involvement of a criminal defense attorney: Retain the services of a lawyer who handles federal crimes as soon as possible. Federal fraud charges can be complex and challenging to navigate without the guidance of a legal professional who understands the intricacies of the law and the legal system.
  • Thorough investigation and evidence gathering: Investigating and collecting evidence involves many steps, including reviewing and analyzing financial records, emails, and other documents. Interviewing witnesses and experts is also critical for uncovering crucial information.
  • Developing alternative theories and narratives: By challenging the prosecution's interpretation of events, you can present counterarguments to cast doubt on their version of the story. Your attorney will work closely with you to analyze the evidence, identify potential weaknesses in the prosecution's case, and build a persuasive defense strategy. This may involve presenting alternative explanations, highlighting mitigating circumstances, or identifying flaws in the prosecution's evidence.

Contact an Attorney Today

Defending against federal fraud charges is a daunting task. Still, with proper legal representation and a solid defense strategy, you can challenge the prosecution's case and strive for a favorable outcome. Don't face this battle alone—reach out to a trusted attorney who can fight tirelessly to safeguard your rights and future.

To speak with one of our Dayton lawyers, contact L. Patrick Mulligan & Associates, LLC at (937) 685-7006.